Friday, November 20, 2026
  • Login
Subscribe
Impact Wealth
No Result
View All Result
  • Family Office
  • Investing
    • Retirement
    • Real Estate
    • Philanthropy
    • Wealth
  • Interviews
  • Lifestyle
    • Health & Wellness
    • Fine Dining & Beverage
    • Fashion
    • Event Coverage
    • The Arts
    • Resources
  • Travel
  • Podcast
  • About Us
    • Press
    • Join Our Community
    • Sign up for Newsletter
  • Family Office
  • Investing
    • Retirement
    • Real Estate
    • Philanthropy
    • Wealth
  • Interviews
  • Lifestyle
    • Health & Wellness
    • Fine Dining & Beverage
    • Fashion
    • Event Coverage
    • The Arts
    • Resources
  • Travel
  • Podcast
  • About Us
    • Press
    • Join Our Community
    • Sign up for Newsletter
No Result
View All Result
Impact Wealth
No Result
View All Result
Home Legal Rights

Civil Negligence vs. Criminal Recklessness: Where the Legal Line Falls

by Simon Powers
November 17, 2026
in Legal Rights
Civil Negligence vs. Criminal Recklessness: Where the Legal Line Falls

Image source

A patient is diagnosed with breast cancer later than she should have been. Imaging revealed something to follow up on but that follow up never happened.

Could this be considered medical negligence? What about criminal behavior?

Medical malpractice (civil negligence) deals with if the proper standard of care was followed. Criminal recklessness may apply when someone consciously disregards a substantial and unjustifiable risk, if the charged offense requires that mental state. The legal test depends on the statute.

Here is what this article covers:

  • Situations that could be considered medical malpractice
  • Difference between medical negligence and criminal behavior
  • Breast cancer diagnosis example
  • Information you may want to collect

Medical Negligence (Malpractice)

In the United States, medical malpractice (also known as medical negligence) typically involves what is called the standard of care. The standard asks what a reasonably competent medical professional would have done in similar circumstances.

You would want to show that:

  • You had a doctor-patient relationship (or other medical provider relationship)
  • Your medical provider failed to adhere to the standard of care
  • This error resulted in your injuries
  • You sustained damages from those injuries

If a radiology report recommends more imaging but never reaches the clinician responsible for arranging it, that may raise questions about whether the standard of care was met.

Just because there was an error does not always mean your injury was the result of that error. An expert may need to opine if your injury would have been prevented or detected sooner with proper treatment.

There are various types of damages you could potentially recover in a civil lawsuit depending on your state.

Misdiagnosis or Late Diagnosis of Breast Cancer

When a patient is diagnosed with breast cancer there are usually multiple factors involved. There could have been mammograms, further imaging, biopsies ordered, doctor’s appointments, etc.

Many times these events happen over a course of time with different doctors involved. Each time the information is passed along there is a question of who was supposed to follow up with what.

Someone examining a delayed breast cancer diagnosis may need to compare the date of an abnormal finding with the date it was reviewed, communicated, and acted upon. That sequence can help establish whether a recommended follow-up was missed and whether the delay affected the patient’s care.

You would also want to consider what type of imaging test was done. A radiologist may recommend additional imaging or identify a finding that needs prompt assessment. Each scenario would be different.

Criminal Recklessness

Depending on the statute being applied, criminal recklessness means the defendant knew about the risk they were creating and consciously ignored that risk. The amount of risk would need to meet the elements of the crime they are being charged with.

Compare a possible careless error with conduct that could help establish conscious disregard:

  • Not seeing an abnormal result when reviewing imaging tests could be considered careless or medical negligence
  • If the medical professional understood a substantial and unjustifiable risk and continued to not take action that could be considered evidence of criminal behavior

Again, the question is whether the person was aware of the risk they were creating. It is not necessary to show that they intended on harming the patient. Rather, the evidence must meet the offense’s requirements for awareness of, and conscious disregard of, a substantial and unjustifiable risk.

There are differences between criminal negligence and recklessness as well. Some crimes only require you to show the person should have been aware of the risk they were creating.

Another thing to keep in mind is that “gross negligence” could be defined differently in a criminal context than what it means in a civil lawsuit.

Civil Lawsuits and Criminal Charges Can Both Arise

A medical malpractice lawsuit and criminal charges can arise from the same incident. However, they serve different purposes and follow different rules of proof.

The injured party (or someone on their behalf) can file a medical malpractice lawsuit against the medical provider that caused them harm. They would need to show that it is more likely than not that their injury was caused by the provider’s actions. Usually the remedy in a medical malpractice lawsuit is monetary damages.

A prosecutor can file criminal charges against someone who meets the elements of a crime. They would need to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the person committed the crime they are being charged with. The penalty could be jail time, probation, etc. depending on the crime.

It is possible that someone can sue for medical malpractice but the facts don’t allow for criminal charges to be filed.

This is something to keep in mind if you feel like a loved one’s death or injury was caused by a medical provider. The severity of an injury alone does not show that the provider committed a crime.

Information That Can Help Determine if Someone Acted Recklessly

As you can see, you will need different pieces of information to determine if someone failed to meet the standard of care and what they knew at the time they provided (or didn’t provide) care.

Some things you may want to obtain if you suspect your injury was due to a misdiagnosis:

  • Any imaging tests and what the results stated
  • When those results came in, who viewed them and when
  • Any referrals that were made, doctor visits, notes, etc.
  • Any documentation that states the doctor knew something was wrong
  • An independent medical review can help assess the standard of care and whether the delay caused harm

You may find out from a chart that a doctor opened the test result. This may lead you to believe that they knew, however, that is not always the case.

As you can see there are many instances where a test result may not be looked at or acted upon in a timely fashion. It could have been one person that missed it or it could have been a system wide problem.

CRICO’s June 2025 analysis of Candello, its national medical professional liability claims database, found diagnostic errors in approximately 20% of cases asserted from 2015 through 2024. 

Keep in mind, these are just medical malpractice claims from one company’s database. It does not represent the percentage of people who experienced a diagnosis error or if any criminal behavior took place.

Bottom line, gather as much information as you can before trying to draw conclusions on what someone knew or did not know.

Next Steps

If you believe you may have been misdiagnosed or diagnosed with an illness later than you should have been, obtain all of your records from your imaging facility, doctor’s office, hospital, etc.

Have another medical professional review your records and give their opinion on the standard of care. Would they have acted on that information sooner? These are all questions that will come into play with your medical malpractice case.

Consult with a medical malpractice attorney, to see what your options may be. If you believe a crime was committed, you can always bring that information to the police as well.

Make sure to keep any letters, notes, or other documents that you may have.

Previous Post

The Luxury of a Trip You Can’t Forget

Next Post

6 Wellness Practices Key to a Stress-Free Existence

Related Posts

San Diego BK Review: Is It the Right Choice for a Business Bankruptcy Attorney in San Diego?
Business

San Diego BK Review: Is It the Right Choice for a Business Bankruptcy Attorney in San Diego?

November 16, 2026
The Hidden Financial Cost of a Serious Car Crash in Indiana, and How to Protect Your Household
Legal Rights

The Hidden Financial Cost of a Serious Car Crash in Indiana, and How to Protect Your Household

November 16, 2026
What Happens After an Arrest in Pasadena, California: A Practical Roadmap for the First Few Days
Legal Rights

What Happens After an Arrest in Pasadena, California: A Practical Roadmap for the First Few Days

November 14, 2026
What To Do After a Workplace Injury in Ohio: A Clear Action Plan
Legal Rights

What To Do After a Workplace Injury in Ohio: A Clear Action Plan

November 9, 2026
What New York’s Litigation Funding Law Changes for NYC Injury Plaintiffs
Legal Rights

What New York’s Litigation Funding Law Changes for NYC Injury Plaintiffs

November 9, 2026
How Legal Help Can Simplify a Complex Truck Accident Claim
Legal Rights

How Legal Help Can Simplify a Complex Truck Accident Claim

November 6, 2026
Next Post
6 Wellness Practices Key to a Stress-Free Existence

6 Wellness Practices Key to a Stress-Free Existence

No Result
View All Result

Recent Articles

900 North Michigan Shops | The Canopy

James Tralie Turns a Chicago Shopping Atrium Into a Winter Dreamscape

November 20, 2026
Joe Bonamassa with the original Gibson Skinnerburst and the Epiphone recreation

Joe Bonamassa’s 1959 Skinnerburst Les Paul Gets an $849 Epiphone Edition

November 20, 2026
Renderings from Aman of Amantaru in Puerto Rico

Aman Plans Amantaru in Cabo Rojo, Adding to Puerto Rico’s Esencia Development

November 20, 2026
Flowering chestnut trees over a village road in Vincent van Gogh’s Châtaigniers en fleurs

Van Gogh’s Flowering Chestnut Trees Set an Auction Record at Sotheby’s

November 20, 2026

Latest Stories

savannah guthrie net worth

Savannah Guthrie Net Worth in 2026: NBC Salary, Career, Books, and Wealth

Read More »
James Tralie Turns a Chicago Shopping Atrium Into a Winter Dreamscape

James Tralie Turns a Chicago Shopping Atrium Into a Winter Dreamscape

Read More »
Joe Bonamassa with the original Gibson Skinnerburst and the Epiphone recreation

Joe Bonamassa’s 1959 Skinnerburst Les Paul Gets an $849 Epiphone Edition

Read More »
Renderings from Aman of Amantaru in Puerto Rico

Aman Plans Amantaru in Cabo Rojo, Adding to Puerto Rico’s Esencia Development

Read More »
Impact Wealth Magazine

Impact Wealth is a luxury lifestyle magazine that caters to ultra-high net-worth individuals and the family office industry that features profiles on the world’s top business leaders and family offices, and investment strategies for the super rich.

Explore

  • Wealth
  • Net Worth
  • Investing
  • Family Office
  • Real Estate
  • Impact Investing
  • Philanthropy
  • Travel Lifestyle
  • Impact Leaders
  • Interviews

About Impact Wealth

  • Press
  • About Impact Wealth
  • Past Issues
  • Resources
  • Editorial Standards and Corrections

Stay Connected

Join Our Community

Sign up for our Newsletter

© 2026 ImpactWealth | Disclaimer & Privacy Policy

No Result
View All Result
  • Family Office
  • Investing
    • Retirement
    • Real Estate
    • Philanthropy
    • Wealth
  • Interviews
  • Lifestyle
    • Health & Wellness
    • Fine Dining & Beverage
    • Fashion
    • Event Coverage
    • The Arts
    • Resources
  • Travel
  • Podcast
  • About Us
    • Press
    • Join Our Community
    • Sign up for Newsletter

© 2026 ImpactWealth | Disclaimer & Privacy Policy

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Family Office
  • Investing
    • Retirement
    • Real Estate
    • Philanthropy
    • Wealth
  • Interviews
  • Lifestyle
    • Health & Wellness
    • Fine Dining & Beverage
    • Fashion
    • Event Coverage
    • The Arts
    • Resources
  • Travel
  • Podcast
  • About Us
    • Press
    • Join Our Community
    • Sign up for Newsletter

© 2026 ImpactWealth | Disclaimer & Privacy Policy