We Were Liars Cast: Meet the Stars of the Anticipated Adaptation

Introduction: From Bestseller to Screen

E. Lockhart’s young adult novel We Were Liars has captivated readers worldwide since its release in 2014. Known for its suspenseful storytelling, haunting atmosphere, and shocking twist ending, the book quickly became a bestseller and a TikTok sensation nearly a decade later.

Now, the much-anticipated screen adaptation is underway, and fans can’t stop talking about the We Were Liars cast. Who will bring the Sinclairs to life? How will the actors embody the fragile beauty, privilege, and secrets of the novel’s characters?

Here’s a full breakdown of everything we know so far about the We Were Liars cast, the production, and what it means for fans of the story.

The Story in Brief

Before diving into the cast, let’s recap the story. We Were Liars centers around Cadence Sinclair Eastman, a teenager from a wealthy New England family who spends her summers on a private island owned by her grandfather.

The novel follows Cadence’s relationships with her cousins—Johnny and Mirren—and a close friend, Gat, who challenges the family’s wealthy, insular worldview.

But beneath the shimmering surface of the Sinclair family’s wealth lies trauma, lies, and a devastating truth that Cadence slowly uncovers after a mysterious accident leaves her with memory loss.

The We Were Liars Cast (Confirmed & Expected)

Amazon Prime Video announced in 2022 that it would adapt the novel into a television series, produced by Julie Plec (The Vampire Diaries) and Carina Adly MacKenzie (Roswell, New Mexico). The project has generated enormous buzz, though casting announcements have been slow.

We Were Liars Cast (Confirmed & Expected)

As of 2025, here’s what we know about the cast lineup:

Cadence Sinclair Eastman

• The protagonist of the story, Cadence is fragile, emotionally complex, and central to the unraveling mystery.

• While Amazon has not officially confirmed the actress, industry reports suggest that a rising young star is in final talks to portray Cadence. Fans have speculated names like Dixie Egerickx (The Secret Garden) or Maya Hawke (Stranger Things), though no confirmation yet.

Johnny Sinclair

• Cadence’s cousin, known for his humor and mischief, Johnny adds warmth to the otherwise tense Sinclair family dynamic.

• A charismatic young male actor with both dramatic and comedic ability is expected to take this role.

Mirren Sinclair

• The stylish and compassionate cousin, Mirren is the heart of the Liars.

• Casting rumors point to an actress with a strong YA following, possibly someone like Olivia Welch (Panic) or Isabela Merced (Dora and the Lost City of Gold).

Gat Patil

• Perhaps the most crucial character besides Cadence, Gat is an outsider invited to the Sinclair family’s summer paradise. His sharp intellect and questions about privilege clash with the family’s traditions.

• Fans hope for authentic representation with an actor of South Asian descent. Rising stars like Karan Brar (Jessie) or Rohan Chand (Mowgli: Legend of the Jungle) have been fan favorites in casting discussions.

Harris Sinclair (Grandfather)

• The wealthy patriarch of the Sinclair family. His influence shapes the family’s dynamics and the haunting secrets behind the Liars’ story.

• Likely to be played by a seasoned actor in his 60s or 70s.

Penny Sinclair (Cadence’s Mother)

• Penny is controlling, complicated, and plays a major role in Cadence’s recovery and in preserving the family’s polished image.

Also read: Gilded Age Cast: Meet the Stars of HBO’s Lavish Historical Drama

Why Casting Matters for We Were Liars

Casting for We Were Liars isn’t just about picking young actors—it’s about capturing the delicate balance of privilege, trauma, and intimacy that defines the novel.

• Chemistry is key: The Liars’ bond must feel authentic, almost sibling-like, with just enough tension to reflect their secrets.

• Representation: Casting Gat authentically will be crucial. His role challenges the Sinclair family’s exclusivity and highlights issues of race and privilege.

• Emotional depth: Whoever plays Cadence must carry the weight of grief, memory loss, and revelation—making it one of the most challenging YA roles in recent years.

Behind the Scenes: The Creators

The series adaptation is helmed by:

• Julie Plec – Best known for The Vampire Diaries and The Originals, Plec has experience balancing romance, suspense, and dark twists.

• Carina Adly MacKenzie – Creator of Roswell, New Mexico, she brings YA storytelling and mystery expertise.

Their involvement reassures fans that the We Were Liars cast will be carefully selected and supported by strong writing and production.

Fan Reactions and Speculations

On TikTok and Reddit, fan speculation has run wild about casting choices. Some readers hope for unknown actors, giving the series a fresh feel, while others argue that recognizable young stars could help boost the show’s profile.

Fan art of dream casts often includes:

• Florence Pugh (if it were aged up) as Cadence.

• Jacob Elordi as Johnny.

• Hailee Steinfeld as Mirren.

• Avan Jogia as Gat.

While these are unlikely due to age and availability, the enthusiasm demonstrates how invested fans are in the casting process.

We Were Liars Adaptation Timeline

FAQs About the We Were Liars Cast

Q1: Has the full cast been announced?
Not yet. As of 2025, casting announcements are still underway, but early reports suggest a mix of rising stars and experienced actors.

Q2: Who will play Cadence Sinclair?
The lead actress hasn’t been confirmed yet, though speculation includes rising young stars.

Q3: Will Gat be authentically cast?
Fans expect Disney/Amazon to cast an actor of South Asian descent, staying true to the book’s representation.

Q4: When will the show be released?
Amazon has not announced a release date, but production updates suggest a likely premiere in late 2025 or early 2027.

Q5: Will the series follow the book exactly?
Producers suggest the series will remain faithful to the book’s haunting twist, while expanding on side characters for TV storytelling.

Final Thoughts

The We Were Liars cast will ultimately determine how successful the adaptation becomes. E. Lockhart’s novel is beloved for its emotional power and shocking ending—both of which require exceptional acting talent to translate to screen.

With Julie Plec and Carina Adly MacKenzie behind the adaptation and Amazon Prime Video investing in YA content, fans can expect casting announcements soon.

For now, readers and viewers wait eagerly to see who will embody Cadence, Johnny, Mirren, and Gat—and whether the actors can deliver on the haunting magic of We Were Liars.

Also read: Cast of Homestead: The Series – Meet the Faces Behind the Drama